Fraud Risk and the Visibility of Carbon

Peter Martin, Reece Walters


In recent years, carbon has been increasingly rendered ‘visible’ both discursively and through political processes that have imbued it with economic value. Greenhouse gas emissions have been constructed as social and environmental costs and their reduction or avoidance as social and economic gain. The ‘marketisation’ of carbon, which has been facilitated through various compliance schemes such as the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme, the Kyoto Protocol, the proposed Australian Emissions Reduction Scheme and through the voluntary carbon credit market, have attempted to bring carbon into the ‘foreground’ as an economic liability and/or opportunity. Accompanying the increasing economic visibility of carbon are reports of frauds and scams – the ‘gaming of carbon markets’(Chan 2010). As Lohmann (2010: 21) points out, ‘what are conventionally classed as scams or frauds are an inevitable feature of carbon offset markets, not something that could be eliminated by regulation targeting the specific businesses or state agencies involved’. This paper critiques the disparate discourses of fraud risk in carbon markets and examines cases of fraud within emerging landscapes of green criminology.

Full Text:



Aas K (2007) Globalisation and Crime. London: Sage.

ABC News (2012) Methane conversion makes piggery carbon neutral. ABS New, 25 October. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) (2008) Carbon Claims and the Trade Practices Act. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

Adam (2006) You feel better, but is your carbon offset just hot air? The Guardian, 7 October. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Ainsworth R (2009) The Morphing of MTIC fraud: VAT Fraud Infects Tradable CO2 Permits. Boston University School of Law Working Paper No. 09-35.

Australian Crime Commission (2011) Organised Crime in Australia, 2011. Canberra: Australian Government.

Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC) (2011) AUSTRAC Typologies and Case Studies Report 2011. Canberra: Australian Government.

Bachram H (2004) Climate fraud and carbon colonialism: The new trade in greenhouse gases, Capitalism Nature Socialism 15: 1-16.

Bailey I, Gouldson A and Newell P (2011) Ecological modernisation and the governance of carbon: A critical analysis. Antipode 43: 682 -703.

Barr C (2011) Governance risks for REDD+. In Transparency International (ed) Global Corruption Report: Climate Change. London: Earthscan.

Barrett R (2011) Carbon scheme ‘open to fraud’. The Australian, 30 September. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

BlueNext (2011) BlueNext spot volume data.

Brown M (2010) Limiting corrupt incentives in a global REDD regime. Ecology Law Quarterly 37: 237-267.

Middleton A (2013) The Indigenous fire project generating carbon credits. ABC News, 18 June. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Chan M (2009) Lesson learned from the financial crisis: Designing carbon markets for environmental effectiveness and financial stability. Carbon and Climate Law Review 2:152–160

Chan M (2010). 10 Ways to Game the Carbon Markets. Friends of the Earth. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Christensen S, Duncan W, Phillips A and O’Conner P (2013) Issues in negotiating a Carbon Sequestration Agreement for a Biosequestration Offsets Project. Australian Property Law Journal 21(3):195-226.

Cubby B (2011) Revealed: scandal of carbon credit firm. Sydney Morning Herald. 8 April. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) (2008) Twenty- third Progress Report of the CDM Accreditation Panel (CDM-AP). Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Contreras-Hermosilla A (2002) Law Compliance in the Forestry Sector: An Overview. Washington, DC: World Bank Institute.

Drew JM and Drew ME (2010) Establishing additionality: Fraud vulnerabilities in the clean development mechanism. Accounting Research Journal 23(3): 243-253.

Europol (2009) Carbon Credit Fraud Causes More Than 5 Billion Euros Damage for European Tax Payer. The Hague: Europol. Available at: http://www.europol. (accessed 31 July 2013).

Financial Services Authority (2012) Carbon Credit Trading. Online website. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Global Witness (2011) Forest Carbon, Cash and Crime: The Risk of Criminal Engagement In REDD+. London: Global Witness.

Gilbertson T and Reyes O (2009) Carbon trading: How it works and why it fails. Critical Currents No 7 Occasional Paper Series. Uppsala: Dag Hammarskjold Foundation.

Greenpeace (2009) Carbon Scam. Washington: GreenPeace International.

Halsey M (2013) Defining pollution down: Forestry, climate change and the dark figure of carbon emissions. In Farrall S, Ahmed T and French D (eds) Criminological and Legal Consequences of Climate Change. Oxford: Hart Publishing: 169-192 .

Hamilton J, Sjardin M, Marcello T and Xu G (2008) Forging a Frontier: State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets 2008. Washington, DC: Ecosystem Marketplace & New Carbon Finance.

Kossoy A and Guigon P (2012) State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2012. Washington, DC: Carbon Finance, The World Bank.

Lang C (2010) Shift2Neutral’s big REDD deal in the Democratic Republic of Congo, Redd-monitor, 27 August. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Langer S (1957) The Problems of Art. New York: Springer.

Lohmann L (2010) Regulation as corruption in the carbon offset markets. In Bohm S and Dabhi S Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets. London; Zed Books: 175-191.

MacKenzie D (2009) Making things the same: Gases, emission rights and the politics of carbon markets. Accounting, Organizations and Society 34: 440–455.

Mawby R (1999) Visibility, transparency, and police-media relations. Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy 9(3): 263-286.

Nield K and Pereira R (2011) Fraud on the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme: Effects, Vulnerabilities and Regulatory Reform. European Energy and Environmental Law Review 20(6): 255-289.

Paterson M (2010) Resistance Makes Carbon Markets. In Bohm S and Dabhi S Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets. London: Zed Books: 244-254 .

Paterson M (2012) Who and what are carbon markets for? Politics and the development of climate policy. Climate Policy 12: 82-97.

Paton J and Bryant G (2012) Valuing pollution: Problems of price in the commodification of nature. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 23(1): 87–106

Pearse R (2011) Making a market? Contestation and climate change. The Journal of Australian Political Economy 66: 166–198.

Prairie P (2013) What is ‘additionality’? Brighter Planet online website. Available at (accessed 31 july 2013).

Peters-Stanley M 2008, Where to Go From Here? The Role of the Voluntary Carbon Market in the Australian Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme. Adelaide: Carnegie Mellon University. Available at (accessed 31 july 2013).

Peters-Stanley M and Hamilton K (2012) State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets 2012: Developing Dimension. Washington, DC: Ecosystem Marketplace & Bloomberg New Energy Finance.

Lang C (2010) Shift2Neutral agreement in DR Congo ‘illegal’. REDD-Monitor online website. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Ross M (2001) Timber Booms and Institutional Breakdowns in South East Asia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

SCAMwatch (2012) Update - Beware of carbon price scams. SCAMwatch online website. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Schneider L (2007) Is The CDM Fulfilling its Environmental and Sustainable Development Objectives? An Evaluation of the CDM and Options for Improvement. Berlin: World Wildlife Fund.

Sedjo R and Macauley M (2011). Forest carbon offsets: Challenges in measuring, monitoring and verifying. Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development 54(4):16–23.

Shapiro M (2010) Murder on the carbon express; Interpol takes and emissions fraud. Mother Jones, 8 October. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013)..

Shift2Neutral (2013) Certification. Online website. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

South N (1998) Corporate and State Crimes against the Environment: Foundations for a Green Perspective in European Criminology. In Ruggiero V, South N and Taylor I (eds) The New European Criminology. London: Routledge: 443-461 .

South N (2012) Climate Change, Environmental (in)Security. In Farrell S, Ahmed T and French D (eds) Criminological and Legal Consequences of Climate Change. Oxford: Hart Publishing: 97-112.

South N and Brisman A (2013) Critical Green Criminology: Environmental Rights and Crimes of Exploitation. In Winlow S and Atkinson R (eds) New Directions in Crime and Deviance., London: Routledge: 99-111.

Thomson J (2005) The New Visibility. Theory, Culture and Society 22(6): 31-55.

Thornes JE and Randalls S (2007). Commodifying the atmosphere: ’Pennies from heaven’? Geografiska Annaler: Series A, Physical Geography 89(4): 273 - 285.

Transparency International (2011) Global Corruption Report: International Climate Change. London: Earthscan.

Walters R (2007) Crime, Regulation and Radioactive Waste. In Bierne P and South N (eds) Toward a Green Criminology: Confronting Harms Against Humanity, Animals and Nature. Cullompton: Willan: 186-205.

Walters R (2010) Crime is in the Air. The Politics and Regulation of Pollution in the UK. London: CCJS.

Wara M and Victor D (2008) A Realistic Policy on International Carbon Offsets. Stanford: Program on Energy and Sustainable Development, Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies Working Paper 74.

White R (2011) Transnational Environmental Crime: Toward an Eco-global Criminology. London: Routledge.

White R (2012) Climate Change and Paradoxical Harm. In Farrell S, Ahmed T and French D (eds). Criminological and Legal Consequences of Climate Change Oxford: Hart Publishing: 63-78.

Wilcox M and Rennie M (2012) Australian Emissions Trading Law. Pyrmont :Thomson Reuters.

Wily L (2008) Whose land is It? Commons and Conflict States: Why the Ownership of the Commons Matters in Making and Keeping Peace. Washington, DC: Rights and Resources Initiative.

Wilkinson M and Cubby B (2009) Carbon scandal snares Australian. The Age, 4 September. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Wynn G and Creagh S (2009) Forest carbon market already shows cracks. Reuters, 3 June. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Vidal J (2011) Peruvian Amazon could become global centre of 'carbon piracy': Report. The Guardian, 30 November. Available at (accessed 31 July 2013).

Yar M (2003) Panoptic Power and the Pathologisation of Vision: Critical Reflections on Foucauldian Thesis. Surveillance and Society 1(3): 254-271.


Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.

Copyright (c)